Music

Sufjan Stevens captures bittersweet holiday feelings in “Worst Christmas Ever!”

By

November 19, 2026 at 10:00 am

“The Worst Christmas Ever!” is the first album Sufjan Stevens has released since 2023. The holiday release features a mix of original takes on traditional Christmas songs and a new original song by Stevens. (Courtesy of Asthmatic Kitty Records)

Acclaimed singer-songwriter Sufjan Stevens returns with a beautiful Christmas music album featuring his first original Christmas song in almost fifteen years. “Worst Christmas Ever!” compiles the best of Stevens’ Christmas songs from over two decades and adds a new song, “On This Christmas (It Only Gets Better),” his first original Christmas song since the release of his box set “Silver and Gold” in 2012. The album, produced by Asthmatic Kitty Records, is his first since the release of his 2023 album “Javelin,” which received critical praise.

The album follows the end of Stevens’ eight-year hiatus from the public eye in Sep. 2026, when he shocked fans by making his first public performance in eight years at Meg Lui’s concert in Kingston, New York. Stevens stopped performing between 2018 and 2026 after dealing with complications from Guillain-Barré syndrome and losing his partner Evans Richardson in 2023, both of which have influenced his music. 

Stevens, best known for his 2015 hit album “Carrie & Lowell” and 2017 single “Mystery of Love,” has been a prolific creator of Christmas music for over two decades. He began creating Christmas music in 2001 to give as gifts to his family and friends and continued in the following years, eventually releasing his CD box set “Songs for Christmas” in Nov. 2006. His Christmas music discography includes a mix of covers and reimagined versions of Christmas classics, as well as originals. 

Stevens has been a creator of Christmas music for the past two decades and showcases his love for the genre in the new album. (Courtesy of Denny Renshaw)

When speaking to Vulture in 2022, Stevens touched on his love for the Christmas music genre.

“Christmas music gets to the heart of the dichotomy between the sacred and the profane,” Stevens said. “Christmas music is such a madcap genre because you get the high art, the low art, the deeply sublime, and the sacrilege.”

This blending of sacred and profane, weird and comforting, kitschy and ethereal is at the heart of “Worst Christmas Ever!,” which moves between funky beats and soft, nostalgic melodies. Stevens’ discography has seen a wide variety of styles, themes and sounds over the last two decades — from experimental electronic music to sad acoustic melodies. 

His Christmas music seems to be no exception, especially with the variety present in “On This Christmas (It Only Gets Better),” which spans from soft pieces such as “Silent Night” to funky beats in “It Came Upon A Midnight Clear (Christmas Infinity Voyage Version).” The album opens with Stevens’ cover of “Silent Night,” a calm, guitar and choral-backed piece that stays true to the original while adding unique guitar riffs. Following the calm of “Silent Night” is a series of livelier songs that feature bright sounds and riffs from a variety of instruments, including the flute, keyboard and drums. The simple, comforting sound of “On This Christmas (It Only Gets Better)” is welcomed amidst a sea of overproduced holiday songs. 

Opening with the lines “On this Christmas / I ask forgiveness / For all the funny things I’ve said and done” in “On This Christmas (It Only Gets Better)” sets the scene for a song about feelings of defeat coupled with finding the strength to believe in a better future. Throughout the song, Stevens sings of struggling to find the light in the world around him, ultimately ending the song by saying, “You said ‘no matter what it’s worth my friend’ / You said, ‘don’t put it past the Earth to get better in the end.’”

This fight between hope and despair focuses more on the inevitability of both good and bad, which seems to be a continuation of Stevens’ contesting with faith despite tragedy, seen in several of his albums and songs, such as the song “Drawn to the Blood.” The pull between conflicting feelings finds resolution in the soft Christmas melody, offering quiet contemplation. “On This Christmas (It Only Gets Better)” is soft and reminiscent of Stevens’ album “Carrie & Lowell,” which touches on grief, love and complex relationships. Stevens once again proves his ability to capture devastating feelings in a soft and welcoming manner, blending hopelessness with acceptance. 

The album reads like a biography of Stevens’ Christmas music from his career thus far, providing a fantastic entrypoint into his discography. While the album only adds one song, the addition of “On This Christmas (It Only Gets Better)” allows Stevens to combine his talent for creating solemn tunes with his creative Christmas music abilities to craft a beautiful holiday song. The album is a haven in a genre that favors overproduction and manages to add fun riffs and sounds without losing its groundedness. Stevens makes a beautiful return to music and proves once again that his approach to the Christmas genre is grounded and serene. 

Rating: 9.5/10

guest

0 Comments