The Diversity Hire: 2026 midterms, identity politics and the case of Xavier Becerra
November 17, 2026 at 7:41 pm
The 2026 midterm elections last week saw overwhelming victories for the Democratic Party, as Democrats flipped seats and took both the House and the Senate, winning state offices across America, including in traditionally red states.
Amidst this blue wave that has swept across the nation, many have celebrated significant milestones for representation. These include the first Native American woman elected governor in United States history, the U.S.’s first ever Muslim senator, the first woman to be elected governor of Ohio, the first Black woman to serve as governor anywhere in the U.S., the first Palestinian American to serve in the New York State Legislature, the first Hispanic woman to serve as Governor of Texas, the first openly gay man elected to the U.S. Senate and California’s first Latino governor since 1875. These are certainly important wins — expanding representation in national politics is clearly something to strive for. However, a fixation on identity can often eclipse other critical aspects of political evaluation, and the assumption that certain identities automatically equate with progressive politics can be dangerous.
An example of this is the election of Xavier Becerra as the next governor of California. After his victory was announced, many took to social media to celebrate, including self-identifying progressives and leftists. A focal point of this celebration was that Becerra was the first Latino governor of California since 1875; comments on online posts announcing his victory often centered their praise on this fact. Notedly, these comments staunchly elided the fact that Becerra, in many aspects, was the antithesis of progressive hopes for California.
Throughout the course of his campaign for governor, Becerra has received heavy criticism for positions and actions that do not align with the image of a progressive warrior he has attempted to project. Becerra’s campaign was built on significant financial backing from corporations and other special interests — including Chevron, PG&E and Meta — and these corporate loyalties are incompatible with the vision of California’s future that many expect him to bring into fruition.
Chevron contributed $500,000 to an independent committee backing Becerra, as well as $39,200 directly to Becerra’s campaign — the maximum amount allowed by law. The influence of these donors has been connected by critics to components of Becerra’s platform, such as his willingness to ease restrictions on oil drilling in California’s Central Valley as well as his continued defense of Chevron and Big Oil. Many consider this as an example to support the case that Becerra will, indeed, largely act as a “corporate puppet.”
Becerra’s inability to reconcile his so-called progressivism with the reality of his campaign has sparked significant concerns about his commitments and priorities, exacerbated by the fact that the governor-elect himself seems to be unable to articulate any tangible principles regarding campaign funding. When asked about what corporations he would accept donations from by the San Francisco Standard, especially in the context of his campaign receiving substantial corporate donations from oil companies, Becerra was unable to name any corporations he wouldn’t take money from by himself, and even said he was open to taking money from Purdue Pharma, a corporation that he had sued in the past for sparking the opioid crisis.
Aside from his campaign funding controversies, noncommitment to key policy promises and clear corporate loyalties, Becerra has echoed the party line, essentially proving himself an establishment Democrat rather than any sort of progressive warrior. He refuses to disavow Immigration and Customs Enforcement, instead claiming that the organization is currently corrupted by the Trump administration, but is ultimately legitimate law enforcement. Becerra’s refusal to align with progressive politics while simultaneously labeling himself as progressive, as well as his inability to generally commit to concrete principles raises the question: Why are so many progressives and leftists celebrating him?
Becerra has leaned on his identity throughout his campaign, branding himself “Tio Xavier” in an attempt to appeal to many voters in California by projecting an image of himself as a down to earth, relatable man of the people. However, his corporate funding and refusal to concretely address issues pertinent to a large portion of Californians tell a different story — one that does not suggest that he is an ally to progressive movements and the communities he will represent.
Becerra’s case and particularly the reaction to his victory presents a compelling case for why relying too heavily on identity to measure progressivism can be dangerous. Identity shouldn’t be ignored in politics — it often serves as an indicator of shared experiences and perspectives that can be invaluable when striving to create representative policies and address common struggles in communities. However, the watering down of politics to solely identity is a symptom of an evaluation system that eschews critical thinking and political literacy in favor of quick and easy judgements and an unwillingness to dig deeper.
Identity is but one factor in politics and it is in constant interplay with other aspects of a political candidate. A critical and holistic view of platforms is absolutely essential lest we fall prey to evaluating candidates solely through identity, which figures like Becerra can use to pander to a voter base while simultaneously refusing to solidly commit to any actual policies.
Amidst a political climate and federal administration that has been decidedly hostile towards diversity and equity, attempting to suppress the voices of marginalized communities, it is important to celebrate wins for representation across the nation. However, it is just as important to evaluate all aspects of a candidate and carefully consider what they will do once in office. These representation milestones shouldn’t be our only indicators of progress — they are not reliable at fully gauging the direction of political progress. Furthermore, all the blue victories that are currently being widely celebrated as historic “firsts” are candidates that deserve to be evaluated by their platform and have their policies heard, rather than just being reduced to a milestone.